CANINE COMPANIONS

Dogs

A Halachic Discussion of Pet Puppies and Dogs

BY: RABBI TSVI HEBER


In August 2020, the Washington Post ran an article that reported on a sudden spike in demand for puppies and dogs which began in March and continued to spread in tandem with the pandemic. By August, a homebound society in desperate need for companionship turned the vogue into a bona fide sales boom.¹ Since then, the demand for canine pets has continued to trend upward. It appears that this development has penetrated deeply into our community too. While the dog has for generations been a choice pet in many observant homes,² the pandemic seems to have opened even more doors. This article is intended to present a small variety of halachos and Torah perspectives as they relate to pet dogs.³

Man’s best friend

The Gemara⁴ invokes the Greek word for dog “Lamas” to explain a pasuk in Iyov⁵ – למס מרעהו חסד – literally, “Lamas (a dog) holds back from his friend’ chessed”. Rebbe Shimon ben Lakish says that raising a ‘bad’ dog in his home effectively holds back chessed from that home.⁶ Rashi understands that the dog may scare away visitors including meshulachim and other guests who will now avoid coming to his door. Although not a firm prohibition,⁷ the message conveyed is that it is not proper to do something that might cause people to fear approaching your home.⁸

A second Gemara⁹ provides a clearer directive prohibiting raising a dog that may bite or frighten people with its fierce bark, unless it is tied up with a chain.¹⁰ An exception is made in a situation where it is retained for purposes of safety and security.¹¹ Rabbi Shlomo Luria (1510-1574) wonders why many are not careful in this halacha. He clarifies that the Gemara refers only to a כלב רע – a bad dog – and not to the type of domesticated dog such as a puppy or even a large dog, whose breed is known not to cause any harm, which are permitted.¹²

It is difficult to determine what should be categorized as a “bad dog” to be included in the Gemara’s prohibition. The opinion of some Poskim is that any dog that barks fiercely at strangers is included in the prohibition even if it is not actually dangerous,¹³ since the sudden fright that is caused may result in significant harm.¹⁴ However, some say that nowadays we can be lenient, since we live in unsafe neighbourhoods and a dog is useful for the purpose of security.¹⁵ Rabbi Moshe Isserles (1530-1572) relies on the latter opinion unless there is reason to suspect that the dog may bite.¹⁶ Perhaps during the time of a pandemic, when companionship is an important health consideration, it is possible to rely on the lenient opinion.¹⁷

Can’t teach a dog new tricks

Nechemia⁸ refers to the “shegal” which sat next to the Persian King Daryavesh II. According to one opinion in the Gemara¹⁹ the shegal is a female dog. The Gemara questions the veracity of this opinion due to a verse in Daniel²⁰ which implies that the shegal of King Belshazzar drank wine from a goblet which was used in the Bais Hamikdash. Can a dog drink wine from a goblet? The Gemara responds that indeed a dog can be taught many tricks including drinking wine from a goblet. Daryavesh wasn’t Jewish²¹ and he certainly was not asking halachic questions. However, this Gemara will be used as a catalyst for us to ask whether it is, in fact, permitted to give a dog a drink of wine or, for that matter, whether it is permitted to give a dog any human-grade food?

Rebbe Avrohom HaLevi Gambiner (1635-1682) asserts that edible human-grade food may not be given to an animal since doing so embarrasses the food and gives the impression that the person who does so is ungrateful for the kindness that Hashem has bestowed through that food.²² Some learn that this prohibition is not applicable if no other food is available.²³ Others say that it is only applicable to the types of food and drink that animals do not generally eat or drink, such as wine.²⁴ Others are unsure if this ruling is entirely authoritative.²⁵ According to Kabbalistic sources, it is not proper to serve table scraps and leftovers to dogs and other non-kosher animals.²⁶ Food that is going to be discarded, since it is no longer fit for human consumption, may be fed to a dog.²⁷ Apparently, according to most opinions, wine that is fit to drink should not be served to a dog.

Unfit for a dog’s consumption

On Pesach, the dog plays a prominent role both in relating the story of the miracles of Hashem in Egypt and in two important halachic discourses. As Hashem wiped out the firstborn Egyptians, no dogs barked.²⁸ Rabbi Moshe Alshich²⁹ (1508-1593) amongst other commentators³⁰ explains that dogs can sense the presence of the angel of death, and they generally react with barking and wailing.³¹ However, in Egypt, in deference to the presence of the Shechinah, the dogs were rewarded eternally for their silence and taught mankind that Hashem never withholds duly deserved reward from any creation.³⁴

As part of that reward,³⁵ the dog would act as the barometer in determining the classification of chametz, both in terms of when it loses its edibility prior to Pesach (נפסל מאכילת כלב), which explains the permissibility of soaps and other materials made of chametz,³⁶ and in terms of how inaccessible chametz must be if it is buried under a wall in order to be deemed destroyed (בשאינו הכלב יכול לחפש אחריו).³⁷

Feeding a dog on Pesach should not drive all that difficult due to the many hours of research that COR rabbis have performed on behalf of the community in developing the COR Passover Pet Food Guide which provides over 5 pages of dog food that is chametz free.³⁸ Products containing chametz are forbidden to give to your dog, but products containing kitniyos are permitted.³⁹ It is further prohibited to feed chametz (even chametz which doesn’t belong to you or is found on the street)⁴⁰ to a stray dog or a dog that belongs to a gentile.⁴¹ Finally, it is forbidden to ask a gentile to feed your dog his own chametz. In fact, if you see a gentile feeding your dog his own chametz during Pesach you must stop him.⁴²

You may ask a gentile to watch your dog over Pesach if you don’t know for certain that he will feed it chametz.⁴³ If you know that he will feed it chametz, and there is no other choice, then the dog can be sold to the gentile and kept at his home for the duration of Pesach. However, you may not tell the gentile to feed the dog chametz or get involved in feeding it chametz, even though it no longer belongs to you because you sold it to him. This sale should be performed through the rabbi who sells your chametz.⁴⁴ Finally, where your dog specifically requires food which is chametz, you must sell your dog to a gentile, and you may then tell the gentile where he can buy the chametz, as long as it is a store that is owned by another gentile.⁴⁵

Dog days

On Shabbos, the 10th day of Nissan, each Jewish family was commanded to take the lamb and tie it to their bedpost so that the animal would be ready for sacrifice four days later. The Shabbos prior to Pesach would be called Shabbos HaGadol due to the miraculous silence of the Egyptians as they observed their own slaves designating their gods for slaughter.⁴⁶ According to Rabbi Mordechai Yaffe (1530-1612) the reason why we recognize this miracle on the Shabbos prior to Pesach, whenever it may fall on the calendar, as opposed to annually on the 10th day of Nissan is because it was specifically due to Shabbos that the Egyptians took notice of what the Jews were doing in the first place. They wondered why the Jews, who were Shomer Shabbos in Egypt, were violating Shabbos by moving their animals which are muktzah. The response was that Hashem had commanded them to take the animals for korbanos.⁴⁶ It was through their observance of not handling their animals on Shabbos that the miracle of Shabbos HaGadol had come about.

Caring for a dog on Shabbos and Yom Tov is no simple matter. Rabbi Moshe Feinstein (1895-1986) is quoted as considering all animals to be muktzah according to the simple understanding of the Shulchan Aruch,⁴⁸ even animals that children play with.⁴⁹ However, some say that Reb Moshe zt”l was not referring to animals that had been designated as pets.⁵⁰ Others disagree and prohibit moving and carrying of pets on Shabbos and Yom Tov⁵¹ and practically speaking, many act stringently.⁵² However, even if pet dogs are treated as muktzah, it is still permitted to pet their hair on Shabbos⁵³ if care is taken not to move or lean on the animal⁵⁴ while doing so. Pet dogs must be fed on Shabbos,⁵⁵ and those who are stringent to consider them muktzah should be careful not to move them while feeding.

Cleaning up after the dog on Shabbos is a difficult matter, since dog excrement is muktzah.⁵⁷ However, it is permitted to remove dog litter or excrement from a home or yard if it is populated.⁵⁸ It is not permitted to clean up after a dog on the street unless there is fear that a young child may become dirty in which case it would be permitted to cover it with a kli, but not to remove it entirely.⁵⁹

Beware of the dog

Someone once asked Rabbi Yitzchok Zilberstein shlit”a if it would be appropriate to recite the bracha of “Boruch Dayan HaEmes” upon hearing about the death of his dog. The Chofetz Chaim (1838-1933) writes that indeed one may recite this bracha upon hearing the death of his animal, since he suffers pain and anguish from hearing about the news.⁶⁰ However, Rabbi Zilberstein explains in the name of Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky shlit”a that the reason for the ruling is that a person is generally upset when he loses an animal due to the significant financial loss involved. However, emotional pain and anguish that is suffered from death of one’s pet does not warrant the recital of this bracha, and it should not be recited. Accordingly, a blind person may recite the bracha upon losing his guide dog, since such dogs are very expensive to replace and train.⁶¹ A person should not tear his clothing (kriah) upon hearing about the death of his dog.⁶²

The Steipler Gaon zt”l was extremely careful not to embarrass anyone. Many people came to him for advice, even those who were not observant. Once the Steipler was approached by a man who asked him to pray for his terminally ill dog. The Steipler thought to himself, “To tell him that I will pray for his dog would be a lie; to push him away would be to embarrass him.” The Steipler then turned to the man and told him that he was prepared to pray for the dog, however, to do so he would need to know the dog’s name. The man told him that the name of the dog was Bulldog Chochee. But the Steipler needed more information. “What is the name of his mother?” The man did not know the answer. “Go find out his mother’s name and get back to me.”⁶³ ∎

Rabbi Tsvi Heber is COR’s Director of Community Kosher

Kashruth Council of Canada | www.cor.ca — 2022-5782 Passover Guide, pp. 48–51

COR, the Kashruth Council of Canada, is one of the world’s largest kosher certification agencies, certifying thousands of products, restaurants, and facilities. Learn more at cor.ca, or read about our certification services at corkosher.com.