Money

Pruzbul: What It Is and How It Works

BY: RABBI YOSEF DOVID ROTHBART


Throughout the shemittah year (“Shemittah”), many Jewish farmers have left their land fallow and focused on other activities. While this aspect of Shemittah is most impactful on farmers living in Eretz Yisrael, there is a second aspect of Shemittah which applies to all of us, inside and outside of Eretz Yisrael, equally. This is the injunction against collecting outstanding debts which are payable before the end of Shemittah.¹

When are debts cancelled?

The prohibition of collecting debts³ only applies once Shemittah has passed and Rosh Hashana of the 8th year arrives.⁴ During Shemittah, any debt which is outstanding may still be collected.⁵ After Shemittah has passed and once the debt is no longer halachically collectable, if a borrower offers to repay his loan, the creditor must inform him that he has cancelled the debt due to Shemittah.⁶ If the debtor insists on paying, the creditor may accept the payment at that point. Indeed, someone owing⁷ money should insist on paying the money that he owes.⁸ A person who has an outstanding loan must write a pruzbul (see section below) so that he will be able to collect payment on the loan after Shemittah has passed.⁹

Are all debts affected by Shemittah?

Loans: Any loan¹⁰ made between two Jewish¹¹ people¹² which was due prior to the end of Shemittah is cancelled, even if one of the parties is a corporation such as a Jewish bank or fund,¹³ whether there is a document attesting to the loan or not.¹⁴ If, however, a loan was extended before Shemittah but is not yet due, it is not affected by Shemittah.¹⁶ Therefore, if someone borrowed funds for a two year term at the onset of Shemittah, the loan remains collectable after Shemittah, since it is only due the following year.¹⁷

Every deposit in a bank is essentially a loan to the bank, and therefore, if someone deposited money in a Jewish bank, he would not be allowed to withdraw it after Shemittah.¹⁸

If collateral is given for a loan, then Shemittah does not impact the loan.¹⁹

A heter iska, which is structured in a way where part of the funds is given as a loan, is also affected by Shemittah.²⁰

Even non-monetary loans are included in this prohibition. Therefore, even a loan of milk or another item between neighbours is cancelled by Shemittah.²¹

Loans Made by Minors: Loans that are made by minors are unaffected by Shemittah.²²

Conditional Loans: A loan that is provided on condition that Shemittah does not affect it, may still not be collected after Shemittah. However, if the lender stipulates at the time of the loan²³ that the loan is granted on condition that the borrower does not employ his rights of not paying after Shemittah, then the condition remains valid,²⁴ and the loan must be repaid after Shemittah.²⁵ In places where a pruzbul is not written and people are unaware of the prohibition of collecting debts after Shemittah, there is a halachic assumption that loans are provided using such a condition.²⁶ If there is a disagreement between the lender and borrower whether such a condition was made, the lender is believed.²⁷

Cheques: According to some Poskim, if cheques that were provided to the lender were not deposited or cashed before the end of Shemittah, the loans are not considered paid and, accordingly, such debt would be cancelled after Shemittah. Other Poskim disagree.²⁸

Items Given for Safekeeping or are Expected to be Returned: Money deposited for safekeeping or an item that is expected to be returned and not merely replaced is unaffected by Shemittah.²⁹ A loan document whose wording specifies that the money is deposited for safekeeping must be returned after Shemittah.³⁰

Business partners who have in their possession funds from their business must return the funds after Shemittah, since such funds are not a loan but, rather, they are funds which are held under the care of a partner.³¹

Tzedaka: Funds that are owed to a gemach or other tzedaka fund must still be repaid after Shemittah.³²

Accounts in Stores: Credit that is offered by a store to its customers or unbilled services that have been provided by a business to a client are not affected by Shemittah.³³ However, once the store or business issues an invoice to the customer,³⁴ it is considered debt and is no longer collectible after Shemittah.³⁵

This aforementioned rule applies only to business owners who extend credit for their service or product and allow time for customers to pay the outstanding balance. However, an individual who randomly asks something on credit may not collect such credit after Shemittah.³⁶

Wages owed are governed by the same rules as store credit.³⁷

Other Debts: Money owed from a kesuba or judgement of Beis Din is not cancelled by Shemittah.³⁸ A thief’s obligation to return what he stole is also not cancelled.³⁹

Someone who denies the existence of a debt does not have the benefit of debt cancellation by Shemittah.⁴⁰

Pruzbul

Hillel saw that people were hesitant to lend money lest they lose their money due to the rules of Shemittah.⁴¹ To rectify this, Hillel instituted the concept of writing a pruzbul, a document which transfers all⁴² debts to Beis Din and allows for their collection after Shemittah.⁴³ Today, the pruzbul is used by lenders who wish to collect their debt after Shemittah.⁴⁴

Some Poskim recommend that a person who writes a pruzbul should nevertheless exclude a small loan from the pruzbul so as to fulfill the mitzvah of cancelling a debt through Shemittah.⁴⁵

The Beis Din

The Rishonim disagree regarding the type of Beis Din that may be utilized for the pruzbul to be effective. Some require that the pruzbul be executed in the presence of an official Beis Din whose members are familiar with the laws of Shemittah, while others allow for a Beis Din to consist of three people who do not have such qualifications.⁴⁶ The Shulchan Aruch follows the former position, while the Rema agrees with the latter.⁴⁷ The custom of bnei Ashkenaz is to be lenient.⁴⁸

Some permit transferring loans to Beis Din in the presence of witnesses even though the Beis Din does not know about the pruzbul.⁴⁹ Many have the custom not to rely on this.⁵⁰

There are different positions regarding whether relatives may serve as judges.⁵¹ However, witnesses should not be related.⁵²

Using an agent to write a pruzbul

Someone who is unable to go to Beis Din may appoint an agent to execute the pruzbul on his behalf.⁵³

There is a disagreement as to whether one may write a pruzbul for someone without their knowledge.⁵⁴

Owning property

For a pruzbul to work, the borrower must own real estate.⁵⁵ Even a small amount is sufficient.⁵⁶ If the borrower does not own real estate, the lender may transfer some of his real estate or have someone else transfer property to the borrower so that the pruzbul will take effect.⁵⁷ This can be done through a kinyan that is made on behalf of the borrower.⁵⁸

A woman who is not married or is married but has her own private loans should write a pruzbul, because her husband’s pruzbul does not include her private funds. However, the husband could include her in his pruzbul by mentioning her loans in his pruzbul.⁵⁹

What is written in a pruzbul?

The essence of the pruzbul is the statement that “I am giving over to [name of judges] the judges in [name of location] all the debts that I have so that I will be able to collect them when I desire.”⁶⁰ (See footnote for additions to this text).⁶¹

This is done when the lender gives the loans over to Beis Din himself,⁶² or by sending a letter to Beis Din⁶³ and the judges signing that this occurred.⁶⁴ It is customary that the lender reads the pruzbul in front of the judges.⁶⁵ Another option is to give over loans to a specific Beis Din in the presence of witnesses and say, “I hereby appoint you as witnesses to witness how I am transferring my debts to the Beis Din in [name of location], whose judges are [name of judges],” whose judges attest to this.⁶⁶

Someone who did not have a pruzbul made and realizes this in the final moments before Rosh Hashana may verbally go on proclaiming that all his loans shall be transferred to Beis Din even when not in their presence.⁶⁷

The names of the judges should be written in the pruzbul or at least the name of the Beis Din to which the debts are being transferred.⁶⁸

The date should be written in the pruzbul.⁶⁹ A predated pruzbul is valid. A postdated one is not.⁷⁰

A pruzbul written at night is valid.⁷¹

When to write the pruzbul

A pruzbul is effective only for loans which were made prior to when the pruzbul was written.⁷² Therefore, although a pruzbul may be written any time before the end of Shemittah, customarily, it is written during Elul, the final month of Shemittah.⁷³

Some have the custom of writing a pruzbul before Rosh Hashana, marking the onset Shemittah. People who follow this custom must be careful to write a second pruzbul before the end of Shemittah which concludes with the arrival of Rosh Hashana of the 8th year.

Questions after the pruzbul is written

Someone who lends out money after the pruzbul is written should stipulate that the loan is due after Rosh Hashana, since the pruzbul is not valid for loans that were made after it is written.⁷⁵

A pruzbul which was lost or destroyed prior to the end of Shemittah is invalid according to some Poskim.⁷⁶

After Rosh Hashana, a person is believed to say that he lost his pruzbul.⁷⁷ If there is a disagreement between a lender and borrower whether the loan preceded the writing of the pruzbul, the lender is believed.⁷⁸

Someone who was not aware of the prohibition of collecting loans after Shemittah has passed is not required to return the money he received as payment for such loans.⁷⁹

Rabbi Rothbart is the Rabbinic Administrator of the Halacha Institute of Toronto

If you have any questions about writing a pruzbul, feel free to contact H.I.T. at (416) 535-8008 or [email protected]

Kashruth Council of Canada | www.cor.ca — 2022-5782 Passover Guide, pp. 54–57

COR, the Kashruth Council of Canada, is one of the world’s largest kosher certification agencies, certifying thousands of products, restaurants, and facilities. Learn more at cor.ca, or read about our certification services at corkosher.com.